Instead of describing a dangerous human face with detailed physical features, crows teach it to others through a direct matching method shaped by social learning (observation) and herd psychology. This transmission process occurs through target-oriented behavioral signals rather than a verbal description.
Stages of Crow Attack
- Target-Oriented Alarm Calls (Scolding): A crow that has experienced a bad event (capture, fright, etc.), when it sees that person again, locks onto them and starts emitting a very harsh, aggressive, and rhythmic alarm cry. This cry is a direct warning: “there is a specific threat here.”
- Visual Tracking and Matching: Mates, offspring, or other crows in the flock, hearing this emergency call, immediately fly to the scene and gather. They observe who the first crow is looking at and shouting at, and exhibiting aggressive behavior. Since they directly look at that person’s face while hearing the danger cry, they permanently associate that face with the concept of “threat” in their minds.
- Mobbing: Other crows arriving at the scene also join the action, diving at and shouting towards the same person. This collective attack action ensures that the information about that face being dangerous is very strongly reinforced throughout the entire group.
- Cultural Memory and Generational Transmission: Young crows grow up seeing their parents giving an alarm and attacking a specific person. In the famous “mask” experiments at the University of Washington, it was proven that even new generations of crows, born years after the original traumatic event and never having experienced it themselves, attacked the same masked face without hesitation, solely due to these reactions they observed from previous generations.
For 15 years, anyone wearing that specific “caveman” mask faced severe harassment from crows on campus.
Striking Details of the Experiment
- Volunteer “Victims”: The most striking aspect of the experiment was that the mask was worn not by the original researchers, but by volunteer students who had nothing to do with the initial event. Crows reacted hostilely, focusing directly on that specific “face” without paying any attention to the wearer’s height, clothes, or gait.
- Severity of the Attack (Mobbing): When crows saw a masked person, they gathered in a large flock around them, emitted deafening alarm cries, made aggressive dives from trees directly towards the person’s head, and followed the masked person for kilometers outside the campus.
- Grudge Spread from 7 Crows to Hundreds: In the original experiment, only 7 crows were caught and tagged with nets. However, these crows taught their mates, offspring, and other nearby crows so well that the mask was dangerous, that within a few years, more than 60% of the crows on campus began to directly attack that mask, despite having no involvement in the original event.
After approximately 15 years, with the observation that the mask caused no harm to any crow and the generation that experienced the original trauma completed its lifespan, this transmitted social memory lost its function and faded. This famous experiment, conducted by Prof. John Marzluff at the University of Washington, effectively ended recently with the weakening and disappearance of crows’ generational “grudge-holding” behavior.
Duration and Fading of Memory
- 17-Year Memory: In the experiment, which began in 2006 with the capture and tagging of crows wearing the “dangerous caveman” mask, hostility and mobbing actions directed at the mask continued for approximately 15-17 years.
- Peak and Decline: Hostility peaked approximately 7 years after the original event as crows transmitted this information to their offspring and the flock (more than half of the crows on campus were attacking the mask). However, in subsequent years, the number of reacting crows gradually decreased.
- Why Did They Forget?: The average lifespan of American crows in the wild is around 10-15 years. This information was not reinforced in new generations because the generation that personally experienced the original trauma died, and the “dangerous mask” did not cause new harm to crows for years. When a threat element did not materialize into action, this transmitted social memory gradually faded, and recent tests showed that reactions to the mask were completely zeroed out.
Related reading
ScienceCoolidge Effect: Chickens and Relationships
ScienceThe Enigma of Deja Vu
ScienceTestosterone: Submission or Dominance?
HistoryTasmania (Island of Australia) and the Story of “Extinction”
ScienceRelationship Between Fear of Death and Right-Wing Tendencies
ScienceCows Eating Chickens and the “Lal” Case
ScienceWhy Are Zebras Striped Black and White?
ScienceAre Men More Shy Than Women?Read more · Science
What Does pH Mean in a Beverage?
Scientific Ethical Rules Need Updating
The Last Wild Horse: Przewalski’s Horse
The Origin and Accidental Discovery of the Strawberry
Why are Asians slant-eyed, and Africans dark-skinned?
How Did Religion Emerge?
The Relationship Between Dinosaurs and Grapes
The Discovery of Gunpowder and Alchemy
Bees and Avocado: A Vital Partnership
Does Smelling Flowers Develop Our Brain?
The World’s Most Expensive Drug
Is Fear a Simulation?
Leave a Reply